Review
Matt Hagen (Tom Rhys Harries) is a rising Hollywood star whose recent Academy Award nomination marks the end of his journey from the Narrows, Gotham City's slums. While partying that night, he meets Mia Torrez (Joana Ribeiro) and, feeling invincible, ignores a friend's warning that she is dating local mob boss Markos Szabo. The next morning, Szabo (David Dencik) and his henchmen ambush Matt, mutilating his face with a knife. Matt takes Szabo to court, but Gotham's corrupt justice system shields the mobster, leaving Matt destitute and disgraced. Back in the Narrows and desperate to reclaim his life, he turns to an experimental nanotech skin treatment developed by Dr. Caitlyn Corr (Naomi Ackie), with horrifying consequences for him and those who destroyed his life.
Director James Watkins' Clayface attempts to walk a tightrope between a supervillain origin story and body-horror; each works in isolation, but in this respect the whole is less than the sum of its parts. The primary problem is that our characters are a collection of motivations rather than fleshed-out human beings, especially Matt. We meet him at the happy ending of an unseen story: his rise from poverty to Hollywood stardom. His desire for revenge after being attacked is understandable, but we don't grasp what losing his big break means to him. Was his rise to stardom difficult? Is he vain or narcissistic? Did he have to make sacrifices along the way? An actor gaining shape-shifting powers would be fertile ground for exploring these ideas and Matt's sense of identity. As he grows unstable, the film implies the nanotech is affecting his personality and morality. But this thread falters because we never learn Matt's moral compass beforehand.
Another problem is that Clayface struggles to marry its body-horror aspirations with its supervillain ones. The middle section focuses on truly grotesque body horror as Matt learns the extent of his new powers, then shifts gears into comic-book mode in the last third. Both are fun and exciting on their own, but they don't feel cohesive side by side in the same movie. There is also a weightless romantic storyline aiming for the tragic love story of The Fly, but we get only signposts rather than any depth.
That said, when Clayface is focused on body horror, it's firing on all cylinders. It's absolutely disgusting in the best of ways, best experienced with a squirming crowd in a full theater. Matt's transforming body is rendered via a mixture of practical prosthetics and mostly effective CGI, and Tom Rhys Harries' performance makes each successive set piece a wince-inducing, visceral experience. Harries is handsome with striking features, particularly naturally sad eyes set deep in his face that shine through the prosthetics, and he also has good chemistry with Naomi Ackie, both of them making the most of thin characterization and making it easy to root for Matt as he sludges through his revenge.
The supervillain side of the movie is also fun, with a sense of humor that's not really present in the rest of the film, and inventive uses of Matt's new powers that border on slapstick when they aren't gruesome. Harries' charisma really shines in this section, in contrast to how haunted he was on the horror side.
Another strength of the film is that casual viewers don't need to know anything about James Gunn's DC universe or Batman to enjoy it. It's a fully standalone story unencumbered by the need to service other projects in the franchise, a rarity for superhero movies these days. Even if the film can't fully mesh its two competing aspirations, it's refreshingly self-contained and more fulfilling because of it (similar to Marvel's Werewolf By Night standalone movie). It will definitely leave audiences wanting more, and deservedly so.
Clayface is a lot of fun, despite its flaws. The horror is surprisingly intense, and the action is creative and satisfying. DC has a real chance to set itself apart from Marvel with movies like this, and hopefully they'll give us more of this type of comic book movie down the line.